How Dr. Beach Rates Beaches for His Top 10 Best Beaches List
Sunday, May 8th, 2011
Every Memorial Day Weekend, Dr. Beach releases his Top 10 Best Beaches in America list. But how does he decided which beaches make the list? This blogger had the rare opportunity to spend a couple of days on some Southwest Florida beaches with Dr. Stephen P. Leatherman, aka, Dr. Beach, to learn the science behind his assessments. He’s considered to be America’s foremost beach expert.
Oh yes, although a beach vacation is fun, evaluating 650 public recreational beaches is a scientific adventure. In fact, there are 50 pieces of criteria Dr. Beach uses to rank a beach with a maximum of 250 points to be earned. Has any beach earned a perfect score? Not quite, but close with 240 points. That would be Hawaii’s Kaplua Beach in Maui.
So how does he grade beaches? He touches the sand to determine hardness, he examines sand to determine grain size and composition, he swims in the water to feel the temperature. He also reviews EPA and safety reports to ensure there are no water quality issues and water-related deaths.
He uses tools such as sifters, measuring tape and geologic hand lens. He also used a dye ball to monitor the water’s current. This was most interesting because it looked like a dry, orange sponge. When tossed into the Gulf of Mexico, it slowly dissolved into a neon-greenish-yellow color and it was obvious where the current flowed. He said he used to use red but swimmers thought it looked too much like blood.
Although there are fab beaches throughout the country, Dr. Beach is concerned with swimming beaches. If it’s too cold or too murky, chances are, it won’t make the cut. Easily accessible is another important element in determining a top 10 beach.
Throughout the year, Dr. Beach visits about 100 beaches and has contacts throughout the country who update him on the status of the beaches he’s unable to visit. Come Memorial Day, he releases his Top 10 Best Beaches in America list. Will any of our favorite beaches make the list? We’ll just have to wait and see. If not this year, there’s always next year.
Can you guess the first beach Dr. Beach ever visited? It is Myrtle Beach when he was six-years-old.




